Editorial standards
Last updated: 17 November 2026
ASM exists to break out of the left-versus-right divide. We publish people of every political view, and we hold all of them to the same standards. These are the standards.
1. Independence
ASM does not support any political party, campaign or side. Nobody pays us to publish an article. Any advertising or sponsored content is clearly labelled, and advertisers have no say over editorial content.
2. Types of article
Every article is labelled with its type.
| Type | What it is | Rule |
|---|---|---|
| News report | What happened, who said what, and why it matters | Neutral. No author opinion. |
| Breaking news | A fast first report on a developing story | Neutral. Says clearly what is confirmed and what is not, with a "last updated" time. |
| Live | A running, timestamped feed of updates on a developing story | Neutral. Every entry is timestamped. Unconfirmed reports are labelled as unconfirmed. Mistakes are corrected in the feed, not silently deleted. |
| Explainer | Background and context on an issue | Neutral. Fairly sets out the main positions. |
| Opinion | One author's argued view | Clearly labelled, with the author's name and stance. |
| Debate | Two or more authors arguing opposing sides | Each side is labelled with its author and stance. Each side is held to the same fact-check. |
3. Debates
- Whoever sets up a debate chooses the number of rebuttal rounds, or leaves it open. An open debate ends when the debaters agree, or agree to disagree. Debaters can end any debate early, and may then write a joint report summarising where they agree and differ.
- An editor reviews each stage and may mark factual claims: claims shown to be true in one colour, claims shown to be false in another, each with a short note (shown on hover or tap) that gives the source.
- Fact markings are ASM's own editorial judgement, not the debaters'. We only mark a claim when a reliable source clearly settles it. Disputed or unclear claims are left unmarked or marked as disputed, not called false. Both sides are checked to the same standard.
- Marking a claim false is about the claim, not the person. We don't call a debater a liar.
- If a marking turns out to be wrong, we correct it openly (see our corrections policy).
4. Accuracy
- Every factual claim must be supported by a source we can point to. We link to sources wherever we can, preferring original documents, official data and on-the-record statements.
- We distinguish clearly between fact, claim and opinion.
- Statistics must say where they come from and what they actually measure.
- An editor checks every article before it is published, including opinion.
- If we get something wrong, we correct it openly (see our corrections policy).
5. Opinion and stance
- Opinion is free, but facts are not. An opinion piece may argue anything lawful, but the facts it relies on must be true and stated in the piece.
- Each author can show their political stance on their profile, and it appears as a tag on their opinion and debate articles, so readers can see where they are coming from. News reports and explainers carry no stance tag, because they are meant to be neutral.
- Authors choose their own stance, or take our questionnaire to find it. An editor may change a stance tag if it clearly doesn't match the article, and will tell the author why.
- The views in an opinion or debate piece are the author's own, not ASM's.
- Authors must not present opinion as fact, or invent quotes, sources or data.
6. Fairness and right of reply
- We do not publish claims of wrongdoing against identifiable people or organisations without strong evidence and without giving them a fair chance to respond first.
- We do not publish reporting on crime or active court cases, allegations of wrongdoing against named people, or medical or health claims.
- We do not publish material that is hateful, harassing, or intended to incite violence or discrimination. Strong disagreement is welcome; abuse is not.
7. Contributors and transparency
- Contributors publish under their real name. A pen name is allowed only by special request to support@aftershockmedia.org, where there is a good reason (for example, a risk to the contributor's safety or job). ASM always knows the real identity behind a pen name.
- Anyone aged 16 or over can apply to contribute, with an application form and a writing sample. Before approval, contributors must give their real name and email, and have had an ASM account for at least a week. An editor approves every contributor.
- Contributors aged 16 and 17 need a parent or guardian to confirm their contributor agreement. We apply extra privacy and safety protections for them, including editor screening of reader replies and a review of each topic before we accept their pieces.
- Contributors must declare any conflict of interest: for example, working for, being paid by, or campaigning for a company or group connected to what they are writing about. Relevant interests are shown on the article.
- Contributors can choose to show whether they are a member of a political party, and which one, on their profile and opinion and debate pieces. If a party member writes opinion about their own party, its policies or its opponents, we ask them to show it on that piece, or we may not publish it.
- Contributors are volunteers and are not paid.
8. Sources
- We protect confidential sources.
- We say where information comes from. Anonymous sources are used only when there is no other way to report something important, and an editor must know who they are.
- We credit other outlets when we use their reporting. We do not rewrite other outlets' articles.
9. Privacy and harm
- We respect people's privacy and only intrude on it where there is a clear public interest.
- We take extra care with children, people who are vulnerable, and people affected by grief or trauma.
- We do not publish personal information such as home addresses or private contact details.
10. Our use of AI
- No article on ASM is written or generated by AI. Every article is written by a named human author.
- We do not publish AI-generated images as real photographs. Any illustration made with AI is clearly labelled.
- Editors may use AI tools as a review aid only, for example to check spelling, flag claims that need a source, or spot possible inconsistencies. A human makes every editorial decision.
- Contributors must not submit AI-written work. Submitting AI-written work as your own breaks the contributor agreement.
- We do not put unpublished articles, or personal information about sources, into AI tools that use the content to train their models.
11. Editing and approval
Every article is approved by an ASM editor before publication. Editors may edit for accuracy, clarity, length, legal risk and house style. For opinion pieces, editors will not change the author's argument without agreement.
After publication, editors may withhold part of an article (shown as a magenta block) or, in exceptional cases, remove a whole article. Both are recorded, and both are explained in our corrections and complaints policy. Withholding and removal are for legal, safety or serious accuracy reasons. We never use them to hide an embarrassing mistake: mistakes get a correction.
12. Questions and complaints
See our corrections and complaints policy, or email corrections@aftershockmedia.org.
Last updated 17 November 2026